NOISE and how to KILL it
This page is presented in a more-or-less chronological order of my attempts
to mitigate the noise generated by my F-150. So topically it probably
will jump around quite a bit, but at least it will be relatively easy to
find the latest info...
(...the beginning)
Fuel Pump
ALL Ford fuel-injected motors (which I believe is all motors since 1991)
have an in-tank fuel pump that is a disaster on HF. Guaranteed to
radiate S5 on 10m to S9+who cares anymore on 40m and down. Fortunately
Ford recognizes this and makes an electrical filter that seems to work
90% of the time (I don't know why 10% don't, but some Usenet searching
shows some failures-to-fix). The Technical Service Bulletin (TSB)
is 98-7-3. The filter install requires
dropping the fuel tank, so unless you're a gearhead too take it to the
dealer to have it done. In-warranty vehicles only have to pony for
the part, no labor.
The test for fuel pump noise: turn on the ignition BUT don't start
the engine. Listen in your radio. If you hear noise when you
turn the key to "ON" that lasts for a second or two, then quits, it's the
fuel pump. If not, LUCKY YOU!!
Ignition System
I guess I might be a failure-to-fix; in November 1999 I got the fuel
pump filter installed (though quite frankly I am not 100% certain the dealer
actually installed any hardware) with no effect. One interesting
thing about the 1999 F-150 is that it is a distributed low-voltage ignition
system. There is no coil/distributor setup, but rather each cylinder
has its own coil pack right on top (at least on the V-8's...the V-6's have
one coil pack per cylinder pair). This has the advantage of the system
being +12VDC all the way up to the spark plug (practically); there is no
pont in changing high-voltage spark plug wires or distributor caps/points/rotors
because there are none!
One nice thing to see also is that Ford has a "Radio Interference Capacitor"
for both sides of all engines (one for each row of three or four cylinders)
shunting the coil packs to the engine block. This is factory standard
installed equipment (I'll put a picture of it here soon).
NOTE I got curious one day and took one of the Radio Interference
Capacitors off the block and onto my Boonton 160-A Q-meter (with standard
inductances) to measure its impedance at RF. I'm happy to report
that the parts RF impedance is <2 ohms from 3-30 MHz.
I have several theories on what to try:
-
I've read on the Usenet that some have had ignition noise problems with
split-fire spark plugs. I don't know what mine are but I'm told that
almost all recent engines use them. Could be that swapping out for
conventional plugs will help.
-
As noted in "Electrical Installation", the engine block (actually head)-chassis
and battery-chassis grounds are substandard. The engine block ground
is only a 1/4" piece of braid; I sincerely doubt that's worth much at HF.
I plan on replacing it soon with some copper strap. The battery ground
is 10AWG; and although that sounds good, an oft-repeated National Electric
Code rule is "ground wires should be at least as large as the largest primary
wire". So I will replace this with 4AWG (the size of my primary wire)
soon as well.
-
I have jumpered my exhaust pipe to the chassis at four points along the
underside with a small improvement noted.
-
Measurements with my VX-5R probing the vehicle seem to indicate that the
electrical wiring system propagates the noise very well. Holding
the antenna of the VX-5R near the driver's airbag, dome light, and trailer
wiring socket generates S9++ noise. The noise is very localized to
these locations.
-
Measurements with my oscilloscope show the noise is RPM-sensitive in both
period and amplitude
Measuring Noise
Two gotta-have instruments to assess and measure your noise with:
-
Good old oscilloscope. Doesn't have to be too fast (my Tek 485 definitely
not put to the test here!). Put your radio in AM mode (no filters,
widest possible selectivity) and pipe the audio out to the 'scope.
Rev the engine, etc., and observe the waveform amplitude and period.
I will post some pictures of my 'scope waveforms soon.
-
I just thought of this one today...a computer with sound card! Really,
there are some really good Audio Spectrum Analyzer applications available
for sound cards. Why not pipe your AM-demodulated audio right into
the sound card and look at the spectrum? If there's an RPM dependence
you can relate it to frequency. An added plus might be if you have
multiple sources you're tracking down and you can separate them in frequency
(maybe one whose frequency changes with engine RPM and one that doesn't).
I haven't tried it yet but I will soon.
Grounding the radio
I have read conflicting information on how grounding the radio chassis
to the vehicle affects noise pickup. Some swear by it and some swear
at it. I suppose the best course is to try both and see how it impacts
your installation. In my case, there was a noticable difference (reduction)
in noise pickup with the radio grounded to chassis than without, so I stuck
with it.
Summer 2000
Did several experiments/measurements on the truck this summer.
The most interesting one was recording my received noise on a laptop
w/ soundcard and analyzing the files with a soundcard-based audio spectrum
analyzer. There are several good free- and share-ware audio spectrum
analysis programs available; I used <name of program here>. To
make a long story short, I can look at the spectrogram of the recorded
audio and tell you the RPM of my engine...so it's definitely an ignition-related
issue.
The recorded files are pretty large but I'll put them here soon.
In addition to measurement, I actually did some hardware work:
-
Swapped out the OEM battery (-) and engine header to chassis grounds, replaced
them with 4AWG wires of roughly the same length. No change noted.
-
Moved the radio to the front of the cab (no remote kit), no change.
-
Took off the copper strap jumper between cab and bed and reconnected it
bed to frame; noise definitely worsened.
-
Reworked OEM cab-frame grounds (one on driver's side, two on passenger
side) by removing straps, grinding/sanding connection points to bare metal
(which they were not to start), applying Cu-No-Ox, and reinstalling.
No change.
-
(2000-10-01) Did some simple ARRL handbook calculating and found that most
of the ground straps I've been using, at 12"x1", are dead before they started...a
12"x1" strap is like 40 ohms of reactance at 28MHz. This is not ground
(meaning...minimum impedance bonds to reduce induced voltage drops)!
So I reworked the underneath and made three new ground connections using
only 3" of strap (6.3 ohms @ 28MHz). I placed them at:
-
Rear of bed to frame, driver's side (so very near the HS-1500 mount)
-
Front of bed to frame, driver's side
-
Rear of cab to frame, driver's side
And Lo! and Behold!
for the first time the noise actually decreased. What had been S7-S8
noise was now S3-S4!!
Gawsh finally a step in the right direction. I will be taking
some pictures of these locations and posting them soon. So next I'll
add more 3" straps to:
-
Passenger side as before
-
Front of cab to frame, both sides.
-
Engine block to frame
-
Bumper to frame (bumper is metal, and just bolted on to the frame ends,
no doubt painted surfaces).
Which to use, strap or braid?
In my readings I have seen different parties state that (braid/strap)
is better for grounding at RF. Well the Q-meter needs more work so
let's check it out.
Measurement samples: 13" long pieces of 1" wide braid, 4AWG wire,
and 1" wide Cu strap at 28 MHz.
-
4AWG 193pF to resonate
170nH 30 ohms
Q=100
-
braid
273pF to resonate 120nH
20 ohms Q=100
-
strap
210pF to resonate 150nH
25 ohms Q=150
Interesting that the strap has the highest Q, but sure enough for those
advocating braid, its inductance is quite a bit less.
Of course one issue with braid is that it is terribly hygroscopic (absorbs
water).